Now Open in Butler, Indiana

Hunt down the cards you've been chasing — from your first base hit to your holy grail

Whether you're breaking in your first pack or building a museum-quality collection, B and C Sports Cards and Collectables is your neighborhood spot for vintage gems, graded slabs, and the thrill of the hunt.

Explore the Collection Call Us
Scroll
1000+
Cards in Stock
PSA / BGS
Graded Slabs Available
Vintage
Topps, Fleer & More
Local
Butler, Indiana
Our Collection

From Rookie Hits to Graded Gems

Every shelf tells a story — and we've got plenty of them. Browse what we've got in store or give us a call to check on a specific card or lot.

Vintage baseball cards collection
Popular

Vintage Baseball

Topps, Fleer, and Bowman from the '80s and '90s — sealed boxes, singles, and everything in between.

Visit us to browse
Graded sports cards in protective slabs
Graded

PSA & BGS Slabs

Professionally graded cards ready for your shelf or your portfolio — from mint rookies to vintage classics.

Inquire about slabs
Basketball and football trading cards

Football & Basketball

From Jordan to LeBron, Manning to Brady — find the cards that define the greatest seasons in sports history.

See what's in stock

Can't Find What You're Looking For?

Give us a ring — we source cards regularly and may already have what you need in the back or on order.

(260) 908-1790
What We Do

More Than Just Cards — We're Your Collecting Community

B and C Sports Cards and Collectables is built for collectors, by collectors. Whether you're buying your first pack, selling a sealed box, or need help grading a treasure from the attic, we're here.

Buy & Sell

Trade in your singles, boxes, or complete collections. We pay fair market value and always have inventory ready to go.

Grading & Evaluation

Not sure what that card from your dad's garage is worth? Bring it in — we'll give you an honest assessment, no pressure.

Breaks & Events

Join us for product breaks and community events — a great way to meet fellow collectors and pick up cards you actually want.

Card display case at B and C Sports Cards
Collection of trading cards
Interior of the card shop
Vintage Topps baseball cards
Trusted Local
Since day one in Butler
Our Story

Built on the Love of the Game

B and C Sports Cards and Collectables started with a simple idea: there should be a place in Northeast Indiana where collectors of every level feel welcome — whether you're hunting for a specific rookie card or just flipping through a binder on a Saturday afternoon.

Located right here in Butler, we've grown into a go-to destination for vintage cards, sealed product, graded slabs, and the kind of personal service you won't find at a big-box store. We know our inventory, we know our customers, and we take pride in helping you find exactly what you're looking for.

No pressure, no gimmicks — just a genuine passion for sports memorabilia and a shop that feels like home.

Authentic

Every card is genuine. Every price is fair. That's the standard.

Knowledgeable

Decades of collecting experience at your fingertips — ask us anything.

Community

A shop where collectors connect, trade, and share the passion together.

Visit Us

Come Say Hello

We're right here in Butler — pop in anytime during business hours and browse the racks, or give us a call to check availability before you make the trip.

Address
4019 County Road 75
Butler, IN 46721-9709

Send Us a Message

Have a question about inventory, pricing, or anything else? Drop us a line and we'll get back to you.

Is this your business?This is my business